Cantafio's Buckhorn Supper Club Menu (Updated September 2025)

Welcome to Cantafio's Buckhorn Supper Club, a cherished dining gem in Beaver Dam, WI, where hearty meals meet a cozy ambiance. Offering a menu designed to please every palate, this traditional supper club delights with a range of options from succulent steaks to delectable seafood. Diners rave about the NY Strip, perfectly seasoned and cooked to tender perfection, alongside generous portions of broiled scallops that are plump and buttery.

This welcoming establishment also features a dedicated kid’s menu, ensuring young diners find their favorites like the classic Grilled Cheese and Chicken Tenders. On Thursdays, specialties like Broasted Chicken and Petite Filet draw crowds eager for a taste of comfort. A standout highlight is the deep-fried onion, known as the Buckhorn Tradition, served with zesty chipotle sauce.

Customers frequently praise the exceptional service—knowledgeable and friendly staff make each visit memorable. With affordable prices and a warm atmosphere, Cantafio's Buckhorn Supper Club truly captures the essence of a community eatery. Whether you're a local or just passing through, it's a must-visit, celebrated for its commitment to quality food and heartfelt hospitality.